Previous Topic

Next Topic

Book Contents

Book Index

Design Results Output

Important Note – These are descriptions to changes implemented in WoodWorks Shearwalls for version 11 and may not reflect current program behavior.

If they are not indicated below, refer to Engineering Design, Design Settings, or Deflection Analysis sections of this document for physical explanations and design code references pertaining to the changes to the information presented in the Design Results.

  1. Design Settings Table
    1. New Settings

      The following new settings are presented in the Design Settings table:

      • Wind story drift limits
      • SDPWS deflection equation (3-term vs 4 term)
      • Non-identical materials on shearline allowed
      • Perforated wall factor Co calculation method
    2. Removed Settings

      The following setting has been removed from the program, so it no longer appears in this table:

      • Design shearwall force/length
    3. Other Changes
      1. Moisture Conditions

        The words Dry or Wet are placed after the moisture condition percentages.

      2. Relative Rigidity Formatting

        For consistency with other cells containing phrases rather than numeric data, Shearwall relative rigidity is now in sentence case rather than title case.

  2. Site Information Table

    The new input for serviceability wind speed for story drift calculations is shown in the Site information table.

  3. Design Summary
    1. Canadian Design Code Reference (QA Bug 46)

      A message regarding story drift referred to the Canadian NBC design code reference. This has been changed to ASCE12.12 for seismic design and ASCE 7 CC1.2 for the new wind provisions.

  4. Shearline, Wall and Opening Dimensions Table
    1. Segment Dimensions

      For walls with openings, the dimensions of the segments between openings now appear, in sequence with the openings at each end of the segments.

      1. Perforated Walls

        The length of segments within perforated walls is the value of Li defined as in SDPWS 4.3.4.3, that is, factored for the aspect ratio of narrowed segments.

    2. Full Height Sheathing

      Regarding the columns showing the full-height sheathing length:

      1. Wind vs. Seismic

        Because the rules defining full-height segments are now identical for wind and seismic design, the program no longer shows two columns for wind and seismic design; only one value is now shown.

      2. Perforated Walls

        The length of full height sheathing displayed for perforated walls is ∑Li as defined in SDPWS 4.3.4.5 and 4.3.6.4.1.1, that is, factored for narrow segments using 4.3.4.3. This is explained in the legend.

    3. Aspect Ratio

      A column has been added called Aspect Ratio, which shows the height-to-width ratio for wall segment, or walls when the entire wall is one segment.

      Aspect ratios are shown for the segments in both perforated and segmented walls.

      For walls and shearlines when no aspect ratio is shown, a short dash appears.

    4. Legend

      The legend has been modified in accordance with the new format of the table and information presented.

    5. Bug Fixes and Small Improvements
      1. Wall Order

        Occasionally, walls would appear out of order in the table. This has been corrected.

      2. Legend Format

        The legend now has consistent capitalization of leading words.

      3. Shearline Type (Change 229)

        Shearlines no longer show a type, Perforated or Segmented, as there can be both on a shearline. Previously it was showing the first wall’s type.

  5. Shear Design Table
    1. Results by Segment

      Due to the increased importance of Aspect Ratio Factors with SDPWS 2015, if a segmented wall has openings, the program now shows shear design results for each full height sheathing segment in the wall. For each segmented wall with openings, lines starting with Seg. 1, Seg. 2, etc. appear after the line for the entire wall. They do not appear for perforated walls.

      Note that the output described below for the table rows for individual segments also occurs for table rows for walls when there is only one segment on the wall and shearlines when there is only one segment on the shearline.

      1. Display Option

        In the Show menu and the Options settings, a checkbox has been added to control the display of results by segments. If this is not selected, the program displays wall-by-wall results as before, except for improvements described in later sections.

      2. Force and Resistance

        The force values v and V, the interior and exterior allowable shear; the combined allowable unit shear and the total shear force V are shown for each individual segment.

        For unsegmented wall-by-wall output, the wall row still shows the v values for the critical segment and the V values for the or the entire wall, which admittedly can be confusing.

      3. Design Ratio

        For segment by segment output, the heading Crit. Resp has been changed to Resp. Ratio

        as the response ratio for each segment is shown, and you must examine them to determine the critical ratio.

        For unsegmented wall design, the old heading remains and the value shown is the one for the critical segment, i.e. the one with the highest response ratio.

      4. Aspect Ratio and Unblocked Factors

        The columns titled Asp/Cub (formerly H/W-Cub) shows the Aspect Ratio Factors for the segment, independently of the Unblocked factors, which will be shown in the row for the entire wall. For wall-by-wall output, the Unblocked and Aspect Ratio factors are multiplied together and cannot be discerned separately.

      5. Data not Shown

        The following data are not shown in the segment line, as they are the same for all segments and are shown in the row for the wall containing the segments, or they are relevant to perforated walls:

        Wall group (W Gp), vmax, Perforation factor (Co), Sheathing combination (C).

      6. Zero Force

        If there is zero force on the wall, the program does not show segments for that wall as there is no need to show detailed breakdown of force and resistance in each segment.

      7. Row Showing Data for Entire Wall

        For segment-by-segment output when there are multiple segments in a wall, the data shown in the row for the entire wall are different from those shown in this row for unsegmented walls, as follows:

        1. Shear force v

          The value of v representing unit shear force is not shown, as it can differ for each segment.

        2. Perforated wall values

          The values of Co and vmax are not shown, as they are not applicable to segmented walls.

        3. Allowable shear force

          The interior and exterior allowable unit shear force are the ones unfactored by the Aspect Ratio factor or the Unblocked Factor Cub (In the rows for segments or for unsegmented walls, the factored capacities are shown.)

        4. Aspect ratio and unblocked factors

          The columns titled Asp/Cub show only the Unblocked factors, not the Aspect Ratio factors, for each side of the wall. The Aspect Ratio factors are shown for in the rows for shearwall segments.

        5. Combined allowable shear

          The combined allowable unit shear V is not shown, as the interior and exterior unit allowable shears are shown unfactored, and there is no design significance to adding unfactored shear capacities. The factored combined allowable shear force that is used for design can differ for each segment.

        6. Design ratio

          The design ratio is not shown as it differs from segment to segment, and it would be confusing to show some data on this line that were for the critical segment, and not others. Refer to the output for the individual segments for the critical design ratio.

    2. Sheathing Combination Rules

      The following pertains to the column titled "C" that indicates the rule used for combining sheathing capacities on opposite sides of the wall from SDPWS 4.3.3.3.

      1. Stiffness Based Combination G

        Due to changes in the interpretation of SDPWS rules to combine sheathing capacities on opposite sides of the wall, the letter G has been introduced to indicate the method in SDPWS 4.3.3.3.1 which uses apparent stiffness Ga of the walls.

      2. Strongest Side Only S

        As there are no rules in the SDPWS that specify you must use the strongest side only, this option has been removed from the list of codes. The symbol S is currently shown when there is sheathing on only one side, but in reality, no rule applies in this case. A dash (-) now appears.

      3. Strongest or Twice Weakest

        The program now uses use the letter S for "strongest or twice weakest", eliminating the awkward use of the letter X for this option.

    3. Non-identical Materials

      Because of the clarification to the SDPWS allowing for non-identical material specification for different walls on the line, all values except for the total ASD shear force V and the total allowable shear V can no longer be assumed to be identical for all walls on the line. If non-identical materials are allowed in the Design Settings, and there is more than one wall on the line, then in the Shearline row of the table, all values except for the two instances of V are removed and replaced with a dash (-).

    4. Other improvements
      1. Nomenclature
        1. Aspect Ratio Factor

          The heading H/W-Cub changes to Asp/Cub, Asp standing for Aspect Ratio Factor, as per current SDPWS terminology.

        2. Combined shear force

          The heading Total changes Cmb, meaning "Combined" as Total could mean total shear force for all segments on the wall, whereas the intention is the total of the interior and exterior allowable shears for an individual segment.

      2. Reorganization
        1. Location of Aspect Ratio/Unblocked Factor

          The columns headed by Asp/Cub have been moved to precede the Int and Ext columns in the Allowable Shear section. Previously, it preceded the shear force values to which it was not related.
          Note that these values are included in the Int and Ext allowable shear, just as the Co factor is included in the combined allowable shear column that follows it.

        2. Relative location of shear force values

          Under ASD Shear Force, the V[lbs] column has been swapped with the v column for consistency with the Allowable Shear side of the table, and to place the more common v value before vmax, which is just for perforated walls.

      3. Perforated Wall Data for Segmented Walls

        For segmented walls, regardless of whether segment rows are shown, the values of Co and vmax have been changed to a dash (-), to show that they do not apply to these walls and to make the distinction between segmented and perforated walls more evident.

        Previously, 1.00 appeared under Co and vmax showed the same value as v.

      4. Shearline Row

        The following changes have been made to the row for the entire shearline when there is more than one shearwall on the shearline, otherwise the shearline row is treated as a wall row in the table..

        1. Eliminated Data

          Several data in this row were unneeded and difficult to decipher. The following outputs repeated the output of values for the critical wall on the line and have been removed and replaced with a dash (-): Aspect Ratio / Unblocked Factor Asp/Cub, unit shear force v, perforation factor Co, design ratio Crit Resp.

        2. Interior and Exterior Allowable Shear

          The Int and Ext allowable shear now shows these values unfactored by the Aspect Ratio and Unblocked factors. Previously it showed the factored values for the critical segment on the line. Note that the new behavior is consistent with the output of the row for the entire wall when wall segments are also shown.

    5. Legend

      Changes were made to the explanations in the legend in accordance with the revisions to the table described above, and to show updated SDPWS reference numbers and terminology also described elsewhere. In addition:

      1. Collector Shear force vmax

        The description for vmax refers to the collector shear force, rather than just shear force.

      2. Perforated Wall Factor Co

        The description of Co has changed from Perforation factor to Adjustment factor for perforated walls or perforated wall factor.

      3. Seismic Aspect Ratio Factor

        The Aspect Ratio Factor is no longer indicated to be specific to fiberboard for wind design.

      4. Combined Allowable Shear

        In the explanation for combined (formerly Total) allowable shear, the unnecessary abbreviations int. ext. and inc. have been expanded to interior, exterior, and including.

      5. Critical Design Criterion in Response Ratio

        The line explaining the meaning of the letters "W" and "S" after some response ratio values has been placed on the same line as the explanation for the response ratio, as it wasn’t clear what it pertained to.

    6. Bug fixes
      1. Blocking Factor for Interior Side (Bug 3188)

        If no blocking is entered for the interior side of a shearwall, it shows a blocking factor of 1.00 rather than the actual factor in the shear results table. However, the design capacity shown is factored correctly

      2. Order of Wall Rows (Bug 2116)

        Shearwalls were not always listed in order as they occur from west to east or south to north. This has been corrected.

      3. Total Shear Resistance V for Narrow Segments (3192)

        The total shear resistance V shown in the shear results segments for a wall or shearline was the total force on all segments multiplied by the lowest aspect ratio factor, rather than the sum of the force multiplied by the aspect ratio for each segment individually. It thus understates the force on the wall.

        As V is just output for your information and is not used for design, this was a display issue only. It has been corrected.

      4. Design Ratio in Shearline Row for Mixed Perforated / Non-perforated Walls (Bug 3187)

        When perforated and non-perforated walls were on the same shearline, the force v shown in the shearline row was the highest force on any wall, but the allowable shear could be from a different perforated wall with a Co factor. Thus, the design ratio compared results from two different walls.

        This was not a problem for non-perforated walls because for that case, all walls on the shearline had the same capacity.

        It didn’t not affect shearwall design because the results that were used to design the shearwalls are shown on the shearwall row. The design ratio in the shearline row was just extra information and has been removed.

      5. Design Code Reference for vmax (QA Bug 7d)

        The reference to vmax in the legend was SDPWS 4.3-8 when it should be 4.3-9. This has been corrected.

  6. Hold-down Design Table
    1. ASD Wind Forces in Legend

      The descriptions in the legend for shearline force has been modified to indicate ASD forces are now used for MWFRS wind deflections, and shows the load factors 0.6 D and 0.6 L.

    2. Perforated Walls

      The note for perforated walls now says that T from SDPWS 4.3-9 is used for the hold-down force, rather than saying it is factored by Co, and the note below the table has been expanded to explain the relation between T, Co and ∑Li, and where to find these values elsewhere in the output results.

    3. Bug fixes
      1. Order of Hold-down Output (Bug 2116)

        The hold-downs were not always listed in order as they occur from west to east or south to north. This has been corrected.

  7. Drag Strut Table
    1. vmax Reference in Legend

      When Applied loads are selected as the Collector force method, the legend to the drag strut table now refers to vmax from SDPWS 4.3.6.4.1.1 rather than the perforation factor Co.

      Co was previously referred for both Applied loads and Shearwall capacity because using vmax was equivalent to dividing by Co, but due to changes in aspect ratio calculations for perforated walls, vmax now also depends on a variable ∑Li.

    2. Bug fixes
      1. Order of Drag Strut Output (Bug 2116)

        The drag struts were not always listed in order as they occur from west to east or south to north. This has been corrected.

  8. Deflection Table
    1. Storey Drift Limitations for Wind Loads (Feature 223)

      Separate tables are now shown for Serviceability deflections and MWFRS deflections. A subtitle to each table explains the use of the former for story drift and the latter for force distribution for design.

      The legend to the Serviceability table has been modified when compared to the MWFRS table to explain the serviceability wind loads Wa, the dead and wind load factors, and the factor used in the calculation of Ga for the 3-term deflection equation.

    2. 3-term vs. 4-term Deflection Equation (Feature 211)

      If the newly added 3-term deflection equation from SDPWS 4.2-1 is chosen, the Deflection table shows only one deflection value called Shear defl, rather than separate shear and nail slip deflection. The Ga value is also shown, and the Vn and en values for nail slip show the values at shearwall capacity vs or vw used to calculate Ga

      The legend at the bottom of the table has been modified to reflect these changes.

    3. ASD Wind Forces

      The descriptions in the legend for shearline force v and nail force Vn have been modified to indicate ASD forces are used for MWFRS wind deflections.

    4. Perforated Walls

      The legend has been modified to indicate that the segment length b has been modified for aspect ratio factors, and that the shear force v used is vmax from SDPWS 4.3-9, as per 4.3.2.1.

      This is not a new provision in the SDPWS, however, the definition of b and vmax now includes a variable ∑Li due to aspect ratio factors.

    5. Fiberboard Deflection Factor

      If there is any fiberboard in the structure, the legend indicates that, as per the new SDPWS provision 4.3.2.3, for segments with an aspect ratio greater than 1:1, the total deflection is multiplied by (h/b) ½. The value of this factor is not listed in the table.

  9. Hold-down Displacement Table
    1. Storey Drift Limitations for Wind Loads (Feature 223)

      Separate tables are now shown for Serviceability deflections and MWFRS hold-down displacements. A subtitle to each table explains the use of the former for story drift and the latter for force distribution for design.

      The legend to the Serviceability table has been modified when compared to the MWFRS table to explain the serviceability wind loads Wa and load combination.

    2. ASD Wind Forces

      The descriptions in the legend for the uplift force P and fastener slippage Pf have been modified to indicate ASD forces are used for MWFRS wind deflections.

    3. Perforated Walls

      In the legend, it is now noted that for perforated walls, T from SPDWS 4. 3-8 is used for the overturning component of the uplift force P.

    4. Bug Fixes and Small Improvements

      Extra spaces have been removed and missing spaces between words added.

  10. Story Drift Table for Wind Loads (Feature 223)

    A table has been added to show the Story Drift results for wind loads. It is a simplified adaptation of the one that currently appears for seismic design, showing the wind direction, max deflection on each shearline at each level, maximum allowable deflection, and the ratio between them. A warning appears if drift limits are exceeded on any line, with an asterisk beside the line failing drift ratio.

  11. C&C Design Table
    1. Extra Null Lines in C&C Design Table (Bug 3035)

      For some cases in which not all the wall design groups are standard walls, and when only one of rigid or flexible design is performed, the program output an extra row with 0 load and 0 capacity for each C&C result in the output table, and added wall design groups not related to any of the actual walls, also with 0 load and 0 capacity. These problems have been corrected

  12. Seismic Information Table
    1. Nonsensical Output of Diaphragm Force (Bug 3185)

      Occasionally, one of the diaphragm force Fpx values in the Seismic Information table would show a nonsensically high number. This was a rarely occurring bug due to unusual configurations of program memory, and has been corrected.

  13. Load Generation Results in Log File
    1. File Header (Changes 187, 179)

      The following changes have been made to the log file header block:

      • the date and time now appear at the top of the file instead of each title block of the wind, seismic and torsional analysis information. The unnecessary word "Time:" has been removed.
      • the header now includes the version number of the software,
      • the program name, version, filename and date are separated by a blank line from the design code information below.
      • The header was not appearing if was seismic only loading and thus no wind load generation section. This has been corrected
    2. Main Wind Force vs. C&C Loads (Change 194)

      Main Wind Force and C&C loads have been split into separate tables for readability. Previously there were two sets of headers for the tables and you had to correlate information for the type of load being read with the correct header line.

    3. Log File for New Project (Change 184)

      Pressing log file button for a new project displayed the results from the last unsaved session. The log file button is now enabled until loads have been generated.

    4. Seismic Site Information and Legend Titles and Location (Change 200, 210)

      The output of Site Information for seismic load generation has been made consistent with wind by removing the words "User Input" and placing it first in the sequence of information reported.

      The Symbols table has been renamed Legend, consistent with Wind output

    5. Formatting of Subsections (Change 201)

      Where a subsection of the report contains more than one simple table, a blank line has been placed after the heading to the subsection to indicate that all the information below it pertains to that heading.

    6. Distribution of Base Shear to Stories (Changes 206, 207,209)

      The Distribution of Base Shear to Stories table often appeared in a puzzling, ragged format because an earlier format with the stories arrayed horizontally was shown along with the current format with the rows arranged vertically. This has been corrected, and the following changes have also been made:

      • The story height was shown in feet and inches rather than in decimal format, which is used for all output reports.
      • The name of the table has been changed to Distribution of Base Shear to Levels, to avoid the complication of differing spelling of the word storey for USA and Canada.
  14. Torsional Analysis Results in Log File
    1. Nonsensical Torsional Forces in Log file for Low Rise Wind Design (Bug 3006)

      After generating low-rise wind loads on a structure with a flat roof, the log file would sometimes show nonsensical output for the rigid distribution torsional forces for low-rise Case B wind loads. As this case has a net zero wind load in the direction with nonsensical output, this did not affect design. It has been corrected.

See Also

Version 11

Design Codes and Standards

Engineering Design

Deflection Analysis

Design Settings

Elevation View

Plan View

Input and Program Operation

Version 11.0.1

Version 11.1